KING COUNTY (WA): Seattle Metropolitan and Surrounding Areas

 
 
 

Obama Needs to Step Up To a Higher Pay Grade

Posted by: Angie Vogt | 08/21/2008 10:22 AM

Last weekend's forum where Barack Obama and John McCain were given individual one on one time to answer some questions by Pastor Rick Warren, of "The Purpose Driven Life" fame, was quite revealing.

When Warren asked each of the candidates, for instance, "at what point does a baby get human rights?" McCain's response was unequivocally, "from the moment of conception." The conservative Christian audience applauded wildly. Obama's response was peppered with hesitation, as though he was walking through land mines. He concluded with the final point that such decisions about when life begins are "above my pay grade."

Obama is still struggling with the concept of "moral absolutes." It's an indication of his youth and immaturity. I remember a time when I believed that there was no such thing as "objective truth" or "moral absolutes."

Then I came across a philosophical conversation between a student and a theology professor. The student made the statement "there are no moral absolutes!" The professor said, "Isn't that statement a moral absolute?"

In other words, what the student was actually saying was "there are no moral absolutes except this one." Is that possible? Can such a statement be true if it contradicts itself? If there are no moral absolutes, then we are reduced to anarchy, where Mother Theresa's morals are equal to Charles Manson's morals. When we carry this idea to its extreme logical conclusion, we can see how incoherent it is.

Nowhere is the question of moral absolutes more relevant than on the issue of abortion. Democrats have tried to frame this as a battle about privacy, claiming that the law has no business in the realm of private behavior. This is just ludicrous.

Contrary to popular belief, there is no such constitutional "right to privacy" as pro-choice advocates claim. Roe vs Wade took the fourth amendment, the right to be free from unwarranted search and seizure, and renamed it the "right to privacy," hence creating out of thin air, a right to abortion.

Using that logic, no crimes could be committed in our homes, because of the so-called "privacy" clause. There would be no such crime as child abuse, unless it were committed on public property.

This is why even pro-choice constitutional lawyers acknowledge that Roe vs. Wade is ultimately doomed. It's just bad law. Washington state legalized abortion before Roe vs. Wade, which makes the case for abortion as a "state's rights" issue, just like slavery was before abolition. The logic for defending abortion has striking similarities to defending slavery. Sorry if you don't like that analogy, but it does meet the logic test.

The untold truth is that democrats are the extremists on this issue. They continue to maintain that late term abortions should be legal, including the procedure where a living baby is delivered after six months in the womb and killed by stabbing the base of the skull. They decry the conservative Supreme Court judges that ruled in favor of banning this procedure to be extremists.

Barack Obama, as an Illinois state senator, voted against another law, the "Infants Born Alive Protection Act." This legislation was written after documented testimonies of nurses reported finding infants who had survived abortion procedures, but were forbidden from offering comfort to them in their dying hours, quite literally, in a hospital garbage can.

Obama cannot risk declaring such discarded infants as worthy of receiving human rights, not because he is such a "deep thinker," but because he has no real convictions about the meaning of human life. He has not accepted that there are moral absolutes. Instead, he tries to equivocate abortion as no different than war or capital punishment. These equivocations do not meet the logic test.

Under certain conditions, war is a justice issue, attempting to stand down evil (as in WWII against Hitler). In some cases it is just and therefore a moral option. Capital punishment is prescribed in the Old Testament as a just response to unjust behavior and is often necessary to protect society. Abortion is the deliberate taking of innocent life and is never a just or moral option. Sometimes, in very rare circumstances, it is a consequence of trying to save a mother's life, but it is a consequence, not the intent.

These distinctions get lost when we fail to acknowledge moral absolutes.

All distinctions aside, democrats are the extremists on abortion. Included in their official platform is the demand to return government funding to abortion providers (previously banned in 1976) and the removal of the "conscience clause" which allows doctors and medical students to refuse to perform abortions on religious or moral grounds.

Obama needs to grow up a little and step up to a higher "pay grade" if he wants to be worthy of the highest office in the land.













 

 
CATEGORY: Obama

Select a Red County Blog

MEET THE LOCAL EDITOR
 
 

Recent Comments

11/15/2008 5:16 PM

Z commented about: Pictures of Fraudulent Democratic Election Letter

It may be ill advised, but it is apparently not "fraudulent" and certainly not election fraud. Forbes has...
 

11/12/2008 8:35 PM

Michael Reitz commented about: Attention bloggers, please file your lobbyist forms...

Lew, thanks for the comments. I think it's pretty easy for most folks to distinguish between paid lobbyists...
 

11/12/2008 7:28 PM

Doug commented about: Self Evident Truth: A Nation Divided

'A house divided cannot stand' if cultural opponents do not honor Law and Order. The First Amendment guarantees...
 

11/12/2008 4:28 PM

Lew McMurran commented about: Attention bloggers, please file your lobbyist forms...

Michael, thanks for posting this. As a registered lobbyist who also blogs I submitted comments that capture your...
 

11/12/2008 1:37 PM

April E. Coggins commented about: Are bloggers lobbyists?

Michael, what is the criteria for "news media?" How does one qualify as news media?...
 

11/12/2008 1:10 PM

Michael Reitz commented about: Are bloggers lobbyists?

Dana & April, the PDC has definitions for who qualifies as lobbyist. Two exceptions are citizens who are...
 

11/12/2008 1:06 PM

April E. Coggins commented about: Are bloggers lobbyists?

Dana, I'm not sure the definition of a lobbyist can be that straight forward. For example, can a...
 

11/12/2008 10:24 AM

John commented about: Are bloggers lobbyists?

Bloggers are considered lobbyists in Washington only if they are advocating for market-oriented or limited-government policies, especially policies...
 

11/11/2008 8:53 PM

Dana Callen commented about: Are bloggers lobbyists?

I do not think that citizens expressing their opinions should be considered to be lobbyists. If, however, a...
 

11/10/2008 8:10 PM

Doug commented about: No More Pity Party

Most people vote on the basis of economic self-interest, and McCain failed to win the confidence of voters...
 

11/09/2008 5:39 PM

Dave commented about: No More Pity Party

Dick Armey is wrong. He states that "Republicans lost control of Congress in 2006 because voters no longer...
 

11/08/2008 4:51 PM

maureen commented about: No More Pity Party

Angie Vogt is a tremendous writer and has served us up political meat and potatoes. It is clarity...
 

11/07/2008 12:47 AM

ARMY WIFE commented about: Barack Obama is My President

Perhaps he can now answer all the questions he had previously said were "not in his paygrade"...
 

11/06/2008 11:27 PM

J. Goldberg commented about: Highline School District Teachers Wearing Pro-Obama Paraphernalia

As a retired attorney who spend 31 years in the legal profession (8 years as a prosecuting attorney...
 

11/06/2008 11:08 PM

Melanie commented about: Barack Obama is My President

I really enjoyed your commentary. It's sad to say, but so many people (from both sides of the...
 

11/06/2008 9:19 PM

Anonymous commented about: Highline School District Teachers Wearing Pro-Obama Paraphernalia

No one has mentioned whether the specifics of RCW 29A 84.510 were actually violated. If the teacher stayed...
 

11/06/2008 4:10 PM

ANC commented about: Barack Obama is My President

Bob, Here read this from a CNN study: "Florida Supreme Court recount ruling On December 12, 2000, the...
 

11/06/2008 3:57 PM

RightThinkingWoman commented about: Barack Obama is My President

David H: You sound like one of the angry old geezers that give conservatives a bad name. Liberals...
 

11/06/2008 12:17 PM

Michael Kerr commented about: Barack Obama is My President

Angie, Outstanding! You illustrate a point in your message which reflects one of the great attributes of many...
 

11/06/2008 12:17 PM

Bob commented about: Barack Obama is My President

Tommy, While I generally like your comment I must take issue with one point. You said: "Unlike liberals...
 

What We're Talking About