CAMPUS WATCH: Exposing Campus Radicalism and Academic Malpractice.

 
 
 

Muslim Brotherhood Visits UC Irvine

Posted by: Jonathan Constantine | 10/13/2008 10:00 AM


Muslim Brotherhood leader Ibrahim al-Houdaiby's peremptory, if not indignant snub of UCI English teacher Gary Fouse's question concerning a damning government exhibit about the Brotherhood's association with the Holy Land Foundation wasn't surprising, as it represents the seemingly immutable strategy of the archetypal Islamist: lie, cheat, and deny your motives, conveniently retake your oath in the spirit of jihadist pragmatism:

Bukhari 5,59,369 Mohammed asked, "Who will kill Ka'b, the enemy of Allah and Moham-med?"
Bin Maslama rose and responded, "O Mohammed! Would it please you if I killed him?"
Mohammed answered, "Yes."
Bin Maslama then said, "Give me permission to deceive him with lies so that my plot will succeed."
Mohammed replied, "You may speak falsely to him."
Mr. al-Houdaiby wants to call himself a reformer, an advocate for "justice, equality, and peace," and opposes the corruption and oppression that has defined the nearly 30 year reign of Hosni Mubarak. But during his lecture, al-Houdaiby expressed his deference for Hasan al-Bannah, extricating the Muslim Brotherhood founder from the movement's succeeding scholar Sayyid Qtub, the latter taking a supposedly more radical view of Islam. The New Yorker's Lawrence Wright writes about Qtub in his book the Looming Tower:

His revolutionary argument placed nominally Islamic governments in the crosshairs of jihad. "The Muslim community has long ago vanished from existence," Qtub contends. It was "crushed under the weight of those laws and teachings which are not even remotely related to the Islamic teachings." Humanity cannot be saved unless Muslims recapture the glory of their earliest and purest expression. "We need to initiate the movement of Islamic revival in some Muslim country," he writes, in order to fashion an example that will eventually lead Islam to its destiny of world dominion. (p. 30)
Extricable from his predecessor? Wright continues with al-Bannah's thoughts on "world dominion:"

Their founder, Hasan al-Banna, had refused to link of his organization as a mere political party; it was meant to be a challenge to the entire idea of politics. Banna completely rejected the Western model of secular, democratic government, which contradicted his notion of universal Islamic rule. "It is the nature of Islam to dominate, not to be dominated, to impose its law on all nations, and to extend its power to the entire planet, he wrote." (p. 25)
While the regime of Hosni Mubarak is less than favorable, the imposition of Sunni-style theocracy is far less favorable. By generally dismissing a government exhibit that mirrors al-Bannah's goals as forgery, and more ambiguously describing the prospect of an enlightened pluralistic society to mollify the fears of an over arching application of Sharia law, al-Houdaiby is attempting to re-package the Brotherhood's vision as presentable. However nuanced and modern it may seem, it merely constitutes a tactic to exploit the good nature of Western society.  Yet, he still remains far from convincing.

Watch additional footage of the event from here.

Comments

gary fouse said:

El-Hudaibi has sent another response to me regarding various issues. It is long as is my response, so I won't publish them here. If anyone is interested, they are on my blog, fousesquawk under the posting, where is ibrahim El Houdaiby.

gary fouse said:

Today, El-Houdaiby sent me what appears to be his final "response". I have also sent him my final points. Again, they are lengthy, so, rather than post them here, they can be found at fousesquawk (http:garyfouse,blogspot.com)

JR Vazquez said:

While I am firmly against racism, I have to say the Muslim Brotherhood is one of the greatest threats to the US and world democracy around. Islam is not a race, its a damn sick ideology, and I cannot figure out why more dont talk about this. While some of our views may diverge politically, as a veteran who has been to Saudi Arabia, Kuwait, and Bahrain, I want to thank you for bringing this up. To many on the far left refuse to accept that there are some true threats to our nation. The Muslim Brotherhood is not our friend, but the end to democracy by using democracy against itself. A constitution is not a suicide pact. No matter what race they are, Islam, is dangerous and seeking to end our existence. This subject should have no party, no ideology for americans, and be dealt with directly.

PRCalDude said:

More people do talk about it, JR. The problem is, the other half of the population is crazy and won't listen.

Anonymous said:

As one veteran to another, JR, thanks for your service and thnaks for speaking the truth about the Muslim Brotherhood.

gary fouse
fousesquawk

Select a Red County Blog

MEET THE LOCAL EDITOR
 
 

Recent Comments

11/15/2008 12:44 AM

Bryan Garcia commented about: Berkeley SJP Attack Jewish Students at Concert

"But I have encountered the group you claim to be apart of at UCI, and I know them...
 

11/14/2008 7:57 PM

Jonathan Constantine commented about: Berkeley SJP Attack Jewish Students at Concert

Being that you are anonymous, I don't who you are or claim to be. But I have...
 

11/14/2008 7:41 PM

Anonymous commented about: Berkeley SJP Attack Jewish Students at Concert

there are plenty of witnesses to yesterday's events, Tikvah members are certainly not the victims. One of the...
 

11/14/2008 7:18 PM

Jonathan Constantine commented about: Berkeley SJP Attack Jewish Students at Concert

I certainly wouldn't meet with my attacker. Neither should Tikvah. Frankly, I don't believe SJP, as Muslim groups...
 

11/14/2008 7:13 PM

Anonymous commented about: Berkeley SJP Attack Jewish Students at Concert

these really are embarassingly barefaced lies. Three Palestinian students, one man and twowomen, were beaten up for hanging...
 

11/14/2008 6:46 PM

gary fouse commented about: Berkeley SJP Attack Jewish Students at Concert

There are two competing versions of who started this fracas, so I am going to wait before passing...
 

11/14/2008 11:22 AM

Anonymous commented about: Muslim Brotherhood Visits UC Irvine

As one veteran to another, JR, thanks for your service and thnaks for speaking the truth about the...
 

11/14/2008 9:24 AM

gary fouse commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

Mr Weissman, I do not criticize the Olive Tree Initiative's aim. If it gave greater perspective and understanding...
 

11/13/2008 9:35 PM

Lee Weissman commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

As I read through this thread, I can't quite figure out why we are talking about the MSU...
 

11/10/2008 5:28 PM

gary fouse commented about: Olive Tree Initiative: Hate Disguised as Reconciliation

Recently, I wrote a piece based on a letter I sent to the Orange County Register. The letter...
 

11/10/2008 4:31 PM

Gary Fouse commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

Mr Weissman, With all due respect, Sir, if you have attended the speeches of Al-Asi and Malik Ali,...
 

11/06/2008 3:05 PM

B commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

Having (many times)personally witnessed the likes of Muhammad al Asi, one of the "darlings" of MSU (or Malik...
 

11/06/2008 2:16 PM

PRCalDude commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

The Qur'an says that Jews are the sons of apes and pigs (Surah 2:65). Any Jew believing the...
 

11/05/2008 7:56 PM

gary fouse commented about: Olive Tree Initiative: Hate Disguised as Reconciliation

Below is my response to the Register article which I sent in the same day:. "As one who...
 

11/05/2008 6:07 PM

B commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

Lee, Your use of the term "Loshen Hora", does not apply here and you should know that. Second,...
 

11/05/2008 4:19 PM

Jonathan Constantine commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

Lee, If I perceived what you said correctly, I am happy that you re-thought your earlier hasty comments....
 

11/05/2008 2:09 PM

gary fouse commented about: Criticism of Todd Gallinger's Associations is Legitimate

To Todd Gallinger: Maybe you should have answered my questions, Mr Gallinger....
 

11/05/2008 1:53 PM

Lee Weissman commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

If you want to explore the legal contours of "lashon hara" that is best done in another context....
 

11/05/2008 12:42 PM

PRCalDude commented about: Hate Speech in UCI's Olive Tree Initiative

"What I saw was a truly remarkable attempt to understand the issue deeply. That you saw some kind...
 

11/05/2008 12:35 PM

PRCalDude commented about: Muslim Brotherhood Visits UC Irvine

More people do talk about it, JR. The problem is, the other half of the population is crazy...
 

What We're Talking About