OC BLOG (CA): Penetrating insights from behind the Orange Curtain

 
 
 

Content Of Character Can Matter More Than Experience

Posted by: Jubal | 09/16/2008 12:57 PM

For the benefit of Sarah Palin's smug critics on the Left and the slopes of libertarianism, I proffer this column by WSJ's Bret Stephen's on the subject of experience.

To add my own two cents to Stephen's point: the experienced Neville Chamberlain was far more qualified to be Prime Minister than Harry Truman was to be President. Yet, the two men responded to belligerent totalitarianism in very different ways Readers might ask themsevles if that was a function of their experience or lack thereof, or if it stemmed from the content of their respective characters.

Comments

Dan Chmielewski said:

So by the same token, then Barack Obama, having risen from modest means as opposed to having everything handed to you vis-a-vis McCain, has the content of chracter to be president.

Jubal said:

Not quite, Dan. Lack of experience doesn't necessarily translate into sturdiness of character.

And the "having everything handed to you" line about McCain is baloney. You don't have qualifying as a naval aviator "handed to you," for example. And as much as you hate to admit it, five and a half years in the Hanoi Hilton is a character defining moment.

Besides, your gal Hillary didn't exactly rise from the mean streets.

Pete Bobb said:

McCain was the son of, and a Grandson of Admirals.
Sadly, in the American military, 'Rank hath its privileges'.

McCain graduated at the bottom of his class. Virtually every naval aviator graduated in the top third of their class rather than at the bottom of their class.

Rank hath its privileges? Was McCain permitted to join the Naval aviators because of family connections or his grades?

Obama was raised by a single mother, and despite this, he persevered and graduated Magna Cum Laude from the best law school in America. Certainly, this qualifies as a character defining moment. He proved his worth in the most demanding environment in America.

My father was navigator on the Lead plane for his B-24 Liberator squadron.
He was one of the lucky 20% from his group that survived his tour of duty in WW II.
He was shot down 3 times. Twice, his plane was able to limp to the English Channel before going down. The third time, his plane crashed behind enemy lines in France.

Using his Catholic Church Latin knowledge, he was able to convince French Catholic nuns to help him hide from the Nazi’s hunting for him until he was able to escape back across the English Channel to resume his bombing runs on Germany. Does this make him a war hero? Does this make him better suited to lead America than a pilot that was only shot down once? IMHO, being shot down should not be a major criteria for choosing a leader. America has thousands and thousands of people that are true war heroes.

in_awe said:

McCain's grandfather was a admiral that commanded carrier task forces, but he dropped dead just weeks after the signing of the Japanese surrender in Tokoyo harbor. He clearly didn't influence his grandson's admission to Annapolis, nor his assignment to a naval aviation career.

McCain's father was a Captain (one of thousands in the Navy at the time) when John applied to the Naval Academy. He was a submariner who was not particularly liked by many in the Pentagon, so his influence on John's admission or aviation career is being largely overestimated by liberals.

If you read his autobiography, the idea that he was raised in privileged circumstances is laughable. He lived in military housing on numerous bases as his father was transferred from base to base. he did attend a private high school, but was not accepted by his blue blood classmates because of his humble (and military) background.

I believe that the character of both McCain and Palin to be superior to that of Obama or Biden. Obama reminds me of the power hungry, slimy pols of Chicago - associating with people of questionable backgrounds and activities and doing whatever is necessary to achieve their own political agenda. No thanks.

Pete Bobb said:

In-awe:
Thanks for the background on McCain.
I still am mystified why he was selected for the highly competitive position of Naval aviator when almost every one of them graduated in the top third of their class. Can you also help me understand this?
Thanks in advance!

加盟网 said:

高品质不锈钢板

Select a Red County Blog

MEET THE LOCAL EDITOR
 
 

Recent Comments

11/22/2008 9:23 AM

Anongymous commented about: How Liberal is Gus Ayer?

Mr. Ayer registered as a Republican to be electable in an interim election with no incumbents. He did...
 

11/20/2008 1:39 PM

John Hewitt commented about: The Darrell Nolta Drinking Game

Anonymous, you have an excellent point. Sometimes people become annoyed by a person or event, to the extent...
 

11/20/2008 2:33 AM

meme commented about: Seasons Greetings to Our Friends...

It’s Christmas again!! A time to cherish the beautiful white snow, smiling snowman, brightness of the Christmas décor...
 

11/19/2008 7:35 PM

orange county og commented about: Gang Members? What Gang members?

hahaha kpc veteran kpc is a wanabe gang that started like a pary crew then a gang how...
 

11/18/2008 11:47 PM

Fred Smoller commented about: More Details On Steve Rocco's Catsup Caper

you can see the documentary I made about him at recallingrocco "dot" com....
 

11/16/2008 10:02 PM

anonymous commented about: Todd Gallinger is the fourth member of "Keep Irvine Great"

Ed Anger, Get your facts straight. Its sad how ignorant people can be. The fact that he's muslim...
 

11/15/2008 4:01 PM

Grizzly commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Disarming law-abiding citizens in the guise of protecting the community is counterintuitive. As you know, law enforcement cannot...
 

11/15/2008 1:38 PM

Blues commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Just another reason to put on my list of things that need to be fixed in California before...
 

11/15/2008 12:25 PM

F&E Fan commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

The judges did not invent a right out of thin air, Jubal. They did their job in determining...
 

11/15/2008 12:16 PM

Bill commented about: Post-Victory Observations On Prop. 8

The loud call for opponents of Prop. 8 to “get over it and accept the will of the...
 

11/15/2008 9:05 AM

COTOBLOGZZ commented about: Sociopoly and the Fanny Playing Card Deck

Excellent - perhaps THAT card deck can be used for Sociopoly, adding GM Executives in some sort of...
 

11/15/2008 12:43 AM

Jubal commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

It's not hysteria, Missy. That would be the tone of your comments here, which are starting to take...
 

11/14/2008 10:58 PM

BigGuy commented about: Sociopoly and the Fanny Playing Card Deck

I have a Freddie Mac playing card deck that was used as a promotional item at recruitment fairs....
 

11/14/2008 10:57 PM

No Dah...Chris commented about: Update on Orange County's Closest Races - Garden Grove, Westminster, Yorba Linda, and SAUSD

Chris Emami, boy you sure daring to stick your neck out by declaring Andrew Do the winner. Any...
 

11/14/2008 9:29 PM

ADP commented about: Moorlach and Norby On CCWs

Mr Moorlach and his part time "law professor" have not been given all the facts. The new "verifiable...
 

11/14/2008 9:22 PM

Missy commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

"What Kevin is threatening would be the equivalent of seeking out my clients and threatening to make examples...
 

11/14/2008 9:16 PM

PMS commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

The more I read on the current situation of the CCW policy in Orange County the more concerned...
 

11/14/2008 9:09 PM

JDAP commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Supervisor Norby; Thank you standing up for what's right instead of what is politically correct. Any man or...
 

11/14/2008 7:58 PM

Jubal commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

What is being attempted is a boycott of businesses owned by people who DONATED to the Yes on...
 

11/14/2008 6:59 PM

Tiki commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Thank you Supervisor Norby....
 

What We're Talking About