OC BLOG

 
 

Will Save Planet for Food

Posted by: Mark Patlan | 07/19/2008 2:27 PM

Will Huntington Beach Mayor and Democrat Congressional Candidate Debbie Cook stand up for recycling in Huntington Beach?  Mayor Cook, who holds a Bachelor of Science degree in Earth Science from Cal State Long Beach, surely knows that recycling is critical to "sustainable development".

Yet, the Register reports that Huntington Beach resists setting up recycling centers. The city Zoning Commissioner denied the plan of a Ralph's grocery store for a recycling center at a store at Brookhurst and Adams because police Chief Ken Small was concerned that the center would attract transients.

Doesn't the small-minded Chief understand that Earth is hanging in the balance?  Doesn't he understand the critical role played by transients in the recycling Circle of Life?  What is more important, saving our planet or a few homeless loitering outside of Ralphs?  And where is the compassion for these poor people who have lost life's lottery, and have been reduced to saving the planet for spare change?


The issue may yet reach the City Council.  Will Mayor Cook should stand up for the disadvantaged and Mother Earth?!
CATEGORY: CD46 Watch, Greeniacs

Comments

Vern Nelson said:

Excuse me, but I am something of an anthropologist over here. Am I right to think the entire post is sarcastic? I think I am safe in assuming it is, some of the statements are so exaggerated and Disneyesque. But... is it hilarious? Was there great laughter on the red-faced blog at the expense of recycling and homeless people? I clicked on here because Debbie was in the tag line, but there is really no news here about her. This must be some kind of inside joke. I hope very much that it is funny. I'm going home now...

Catholic Boy said:

HB already recycles more than any other city in the Red County, factually speaking

maynard g. krebs said:

Rainbow Disposal, which performs trash pickup in Huntington Beach, recycles nearly everything they get. They just got an award from the League of Conservation for their outstanding efforts at reducing the amount of waste they send to landfills. Their goal is to send nothing to landfills.

So, whatever would go to this recycling center is already being recycled anyway.

The only issues then are this: Do transients represent a threat to local residents? Should there be more of these centers at supermarkets so that low-income residents have more access? Should the city ban what essentially is an allowable use, restricting free enterprise?

Mark Patlan said:

Vern,

Satirical, yes. Disneyesque? The phrases and arguments used are recycled Democrat, left-wing, liberal catch-phrases. If they are exaggerated, then that came from the source.

I am simply drawing attention to a story that raises several issues (as Maynard points out), and asking where Debbie Cook stands because she has made environmentalism central to her campaign.

It seems hypocritical for a pro-environmentalist city or candidate to oppose a recycling center out of hostility towards the homeless. Does Debbie Cook, the highest elected official in HB have the political courage to stand up for the recycling center (and the homeless who would benefit economically picking up HB litter)?

Vern Nelson said:

I'll let you know, bro, when I find out. This story hasn't really come onto most of our radar screens out here in HB.

I still can't tell whether you really care about the environment and the homeless or whether you think they're both silly concerns. Maybe you're just trying to have it both ways, for cheap laughs.

I guess when I do similar satire of rightwing causes over at my blog, I think I at least make it clear what I'm for and against. (Unless I'm just making fun of something I think is totally ridiculous like everyone's fixation on Paul Lucas last April.)

Mark Patlan said:

I'm critical of top-down command-and-control recycling mandates, and skeptical of the motives of many in the environmentalist movement. (Recycling of some materials, but not all, makes good economic sense.)

I'm opposed to arbitrary governmental interference with people's right to earn a living. Cities may enforce zoning to protect public health and safety. For example, cities may use zoning to regulate adult-oriented businesses because of the crime associated with such businesses. In this case, HB seems to be equating homelessness with crime.

Having some personal experience with the homeless, I can tell you that many are mentally ill (self-medicating) substance abusers (hence, the photo) who are incapable of holding down a job, but pose little threat to public safety.

Given the economic incentives created by California recycling law, it seems only rational that these people would make money gathering recyclables.

Vern Nelson said:

Well, unless there's more to this particular kerfluffle than I know yet, I'd say I agree with you. If it comes to council we'll see what Debbie thinks. I think some of you conservatives over here will find she's a lot more reasonable than you think, especially compared to crazy Dana.

Catholic Boy said:

Mark,

But apparently you aren't concerned that the Chief of Police is concerned with potential crime. Potential crime, or even a potentially unsafe situation, trumps recycling.

Makes your entire thought process too "suspect" for my sensibilities

Mark Patlan said:

I'm old school when it comes to economic liberty.

Our Constitution once protected economic liberty, the right to earn a living - a liberty in our legal tradition dating back to Magna Carta in 1215, as documented by the late law Prof. Bernard H. Siegan (who I was a student of).

It was New Deal liberals and statists who destroyed this right, ushering in the era of nanny state economic regulation. I simply favor economic liberty and don't believe that the state has made a sufficient showing to justify blocking a lawful business (that happens to be recycling. I don't sit in judgment over the wisdom of whether HB needs a recycling business or no, any more than I would sit in judgment over whether HB needs a bookstore or grocery market.)

Leave a comment

 

Type the characters you see in the picture above.

 

SPONSORED LINKS

Community: Get Involved

Blogpen Login RSS Feeds Daily Dose
Please Enter Your E-Mail Address


Advertise Here

Comments

Jubal commented about

Obama Rex

08/28/2008 6:58 PM

oc in the Know commented about

Obama Rex

08/28/2008 6:50 PM

Bolsaman commented about

Mayor Margie Rice Moved to Remove Janet's Bridge from Agenda

08/28/2008 6:28 PM

BolsaWatcher commented about

Mayor Margie Rice Moved to Remove Janet's Bridge from Agenda

08/28/2008 5:15 PM

Lam Pho commented about

Mayor Margie Rice Moved to Remove Janet's Bridge from Agenda

08/28/2008 5:12 PM

Ha Ha commented about

Superior Court Run-Off: Carillo Gets Early Press

08/28/2008 4:29 PM

One who was there... commented about

Westminster Council to Discuss "Bolsa Bridge" Tonight

08/28/2008 4:25 PM

Sean H. Mill commented about

DPOC Endorses Paul Lucas; Rejected Linh Ho and Robin Marcario

08/28/2008 3:50 PM

Lin Lin Lin.... commented about

DPOC Endorses Paul Lucas; Rejected Linh Ho and Robin Marcario

08/28/2008 3:46 PM

WCP commented about

Anti-Hutchens' CCW Group Formed

08/28/2008 3:39 PM

Morgan commented about

DPOC Endorses Paul Lucas; Rejected Linh Ho and Robin Marcario

08/28/2008 3:28 PM

Nguyen Hung commented about

Mayor Margie Rice Moved to Remove Janet's Bridge from Agenda

08/28/2008 3:24 PM

Lin Lin Lin..... commented about

DPOC Endorses Paul Lucas; Rejected Linh Ho and Robin Marcario

08/28/2008 3:22 PM

Eric Hall commented about

Irvine Open Thread

08/28/2008 3:01 PM

Joe Holtzman commented about

MV Councilman Frank Ury Re-Election Fundraiser On Sept. 9

08/28/2008 2:58 PM

Categories

1st Supe District Watch (149)
1st Supervisor District (19)
1st Supervisor District Special Election (350)
2006 Races (1)
2007 Wildfires (11)
2008 Elections (136)
2010 Elections (1)
241 Tollroad (66)
33rd Senate District (11)
34th Senate District (6)
4th Supervisor District (1)
AD60 Watch (69)
AD71 Watch (103)
AD73 Watch (17)
Add category (1)
AHUSD Special Election Drive (9)
At The Trough (92)
Blogworld Expo 2007 (1)
Buena Park (1)
California Stuff (290)
Carol Rudat (6)
CD46 Watch (19)
CD47 Watch (11)
CUSD Recall (27)
Daily News Roundup - 2008 (181)
Daily News Roundup -- 2007 (309)
Debbie Cook Ballot Title Lawsuit (3)
Erwin Chemerinsky (1)
Fairness Doctrine (1)
FEATURE (36)
Fullerton (3)
Fund 130 Watch (1)
Garden Grove (2)
General OC Stuff (68)
Greeniacs (8)
Harkey Agonistes (8)
In re Rachel Home School Ruling (1)
Irvine Mayor's Race (4)
Ladera Peaker Plant (1)
Leftosphere (2)
Liberty (64)
Loretta for Governor (2)
Making of the President (51)
Making of the President 2008 (67)
Measure D (1)
Measure M Renewal (1)
Mike Carona (62)
Monsignor John Urell (13)
National Stuff (57)
Nativo Lopez (1)
Newport Beach (1)
News (31)
Nimby Mouse (45)
NIMBY Watch (1)
OC Blogosphere (60)
OC Blogpourri (7)
OC Judge Races (40)
OC Parks (2)
OC Register Website Lameness (2)
OC Sheriff's Department (47)
OC's Next Sheriff (83)
OC/DC (17)
OCTA (20)
Old School (4)
OUSD (14)
Politics Behind the Orange Curtain (519)
Property Rights (14)
Raymond Chandler Quote of the Week (28)
Red County blogs (5)
Red County magazine (3)
Red County Radio (25)
Retroactive Pension Rescission (23)
SanTana (4)
SD29 Watch (7)
SD33 Watch (97)
SD34 Watch (1)
SD35 Watch (13)
Steve Ambriz (1)
Tan Nguyen (1)
The 3rd Floor (6)
The 5th Floor (146)
The New Majority (3)
The Perils of Chriss Street (29)
The Sheriff's Race (2)
Theo Lacy (1)
TIN CUP 2 (16)
Transportation (31)
Viet Politics (41)