SD33 Watch: Grand Jury Calls Mimi's Mailer Deceptive
Posted by: Tomahawk | 05/21/2008 8:51 PM
In case you have not been paying attention, the Mimi Walters for Senate campaign sent out this mailer attacking Harry Sidhu on illegal immigration. The envelope was cleverly designed to look as if it actually came from the Orange County Grand Jury instead of the Friends of Mimi Walters.
As reported by Jubal earlier, Harry Sidhu held a press conference outside of the Anaheim City Hall to condemn the hit piece.
Then a few hours later the real Orange County Grand Jury sent out this press release to Martin Wisckol expressing their disapproval of the Mimi Walters for Senate campaign for sending out something that is, "deceptive and misleading..."
As reported by Jubal earlier, Harry Sidhu held a press conference outside of the Anaheim City Hall to condemn the hit piece.Then a few hours later the real Orange County Grand Jury sent out this press release to Martin Wisckol expressing their disapproval of the Mimi Walters for Senate campaign for sending out something that is, "deceptive and misleading..."
CATEGORY:
SD33 Watch


the same group that endorses Moorlach's lame local FPPC ordinance? Logos are re-created all the time. That mailer was totally legal.
Ann Avery Andres needs to grab a copy of the Bill of Rights and read it ASAP.
It was deceptive and misleading. So was the content. The genius responsible for it should step to the plate and profess his idiocity.
The OC Grand Jury is completely asleep for years while Carona is doing his funny business, but wakes up when a candidate dares to use their logo.
How many more pro-Sidhu posts is OC Blog going to allow Tomahawk to make without confessing that he's on the Sidhu dole?
Or the Dina Dole
Payroll and Dole:
The truth hurts, huh? There's no room for deceptive and dirty campaigning tactics. Dave Gilliard should know better but he can't seem to help himself. Mimi Walters should not be screaming fire when she's the one lighting the match.
Trying desperately to shoot the messenger for the message? Old trick won't work. The message is still Mimi Walters plays in the gutter and do anything to win. Shame on her and her supporters for trying so hard to negate this misdeed.
10:40 PM
I'm not on Harry's payroll nor Mimi's, although maybe I should at least get something as you suggested.
The post was simply about what happened, I didn't even inject my opinion into it, but again maybe your blind support for a certain candidate is warping your basic comprehension of the English language.
The mailer was deceptive, legal (because she complied with the Reform Act's Sender Identification requirements by identifying her committee on the back) but deceptive.
If a business sent this mailer, they could be sued under California's Unfair Business Practices laws. A different legal standard for political speech applies, but the mailer was deceptive.
"I'm shocked - shocked! - to find that gambling is going on in here."
Harry Sidhu's silly press conference was deceptive as well, shredding mailers he has already sent out.
And we wonder why we ended up with that bunch of winners in Washington - corrupt swine that put is the minority, where we belong.
Well at least Mimi and Harry are duking it out in English so we can all understand what they are doing. They aren't speaking in a language other than English on their own separate radio broadcasts sniping at each other for their own constituencies. Or, maybe we should check up on those radio stations....maybe they are talking about Harry and Mimi on those late night non-English speaking radio programs and we just don't know it!!
Shame on Mimi Walters and her supporters including Jubal for their deceptive, racist, misleading attacks on Harry Sidhu. Gillard, what's going to be your next lie? Falsifying th seal of the US Congress? You're bunch of unethical jerks.
Have you seen Harry and his supporters' deceptive, sexist, misleading attacks on Mimi??? That camp started all this due to Harry's inability to logically discuss the issues. Don't call anyone unethical jerks until you've examined your own group's ethics.
...well before any "retaliation" from Walters. Harry Sidhu continued to carry out sexist attacks on Mimi Walters up to his phoney press conference.
This press conference was all deception. Harry Sidhu has spent more on negative attacks against a political opponent than any other candidate we have seen in the last two years! He should be in the Hall of Fame of negative politics!
Instead, he has the audacity to call a press conference to give up negative politics?!
Exercise intelligence. Don't believe Harry Sidhu's lies.
Oh, my God! If someone else does something wrong it that does not make you right. Who taught you morals? I'd love to have a talk with your parents. My grandson knows better. If you're so proud of yourself for falsifying the OC Grand Jury Letter, tomorrow you'll end up like Mike Corona. You should be embarrassed of yourself. Mimi Walters lost all credibility, whatsoever. I'm going to vote for Harry Sidhu.
Politics is a two-way street. Grandparents should teach their children that lesson.
Harry Sidhu has lied over and over and over. He escalated the tone of this campaign more than any other individual, spending boat loads of cash on negative mail pieces and attack ads.
Right on to the OC Grand Jury for calling the Walters camp on this misleading and deceptive campaign tactic.
Is Mimi Walters slipping in the polls by that many points against Sidhu so to cheat and lie blatantly like that?
Using the OC Grand Jury to get ahead and getting slapped by it is shameful. Very shameful. Do we really want our state legislators to cheat and lie without blinking? Doesn't Mimi and her consultant Gilliard have no shame or any sense of self respect?
I totally agree with you. It is shameful and embarrassing to intentionally falsify the OC Grand Jury letter and lie about your opponent to the voters. The last person I would expect it from is elected official like Mimi Walters.
Is this is how you intend to represent us in senate?? by the means of cheating and lying whenever it suits you?? You need to send voters an apology for this, and you need to apologize to Orange County Grand Jury, and you need to apologize to Harry Sidhu again.
Get your facts straight, nobody intentionally falsified an OC Grand Jury letter and lied about Harry Sidhu to the voters. The somewhat misleading letter was filled with the truth about Harry but his supporters are uncomfortable with the facts so they escalate their rhetoric to cover their shame. Mimi's record speaks for itself (if Harryites would bother to review it) and so we know exactly how she will represent us in the senate.
So the spinning wheel keeps turning on this. Unbelievable. Blind faith is at work it seems. What part of the OC Grand Jury condemning the mailer as misleading and deceptive can't these commenters understand. Somewhat misleading they say? What a laugh.
It wouldn't surprise me that the Grand Jury might just investigatye this themselves for potential charges against Mimi Walters. How could she be so stupid to let Gilliard pull this stunt and jeopardize her reputation? What was to be gained by dragging the Grand Jury, and now the OC Register's editorial department into the fray?
Dumb, dumb, dumb. If she loses this election, it will be because of her own stupidity.
The Grand Jury anti-Sidhu mailer was clearly marked as coming from the Walters for Senate campaign. There wasn't anything deceptive about it. The Grand Jury did, in fact, disapprove of the City of Anaheim's handling of the illegal immigration issue. There isn't anything wrong with that.
I'm getting sick of Harry Sidhu and his supporters advocating against free speech. First Amendment kiddos!
Defend free speech, vote Mimi Walters.
Gotta love reading the continued spin attempts. The OC Grand Jury "never" disapproved of Anaheim's handling of the illegal immigration issue. It's like that old telephone game where the story keeps changing. What a crock. Keep trying to spin those facts to try and justify the misleading and deceptive tactics used by Walters.
Gilliard has no choice but to try and continue the spin. He has brought needless public ridicule of his client in the form of a rebuke from the Grand Jury as well as Orange County's major newspaper editorial staff. There is no way around it. And if Mimi Walters does get investigated by the Grand Jury for potential mail fraud, which this could be construed to be, then she will do jail time. Way to go Gilliard and Wysocki. You guys are real pieces of work.
Mail fraud?! Ha ha ha ha! You obviously aren't an attorney.
The envelope was clearly labeled on the back and there was no attempt to unlawfully obtain money or personal information from recipients.
What a ridiculous and foolish allegation.
It's free political speech. End of. You want to regulate free speech because it doesn't suit you.
When is the press going to call out the Sidhu campaign for it's idiocy?
The OC Grand Jury Press Release said it all. Deceptive and misleading campaign tactics cannot be brushed under the rug.
Mimi is way over the top! Even Barbara Coe, founder of the California Coalition for Immigration Reform said that "It [the mailer] sounds like it's totally distorting the situation, [t]he last I heard, they were doing a very good job in Anaheim. It looks like Mimi is going a little over the top." If Mimi has to resort to tactics as brutish and immature as sending fake government documents then she really must be slipping. I'm a little worried that an Assemblywoman would imitate government papers for her own gain, makes me wonder what else she's capable of!
Now, Walters is the defender of Free Speech!
I guess patriotism is the last refuge of a scoundrel!
It is just shameful for Assemblywoman Walters to fake government documents. There's no way around it.
"Extremism in the defense of liberty is not a vice."
Mimi Walters has my vote.
For throwing a completely disingenuine press conference. The guy has lived by negative campaigning. What a lame-o candidate!
Yeah, like "Goldwater" and "Shame on Sidhu" aren't the same person (Walters' campaigners. Tee hee. Gee, you fooled us all.)
I think David Frum sums up these two candidates' campaign in his book "Comeback":
"But tabloid media beget tabloid politics. When you argue stupid, you campaign stupid. When you campaign stupid, you win stupid. And when you win stupid, you govern stupid."
That's why it makes little difference who wins this race, because either way we'll get stupid governance - in other words, the status quo.