OC BLOG (CA): Penetrating insights from behind the Orange Curtain

 
 
 

The Prophetic Voice in the Wilderness that is Mark Steyn

Posted by: David Bahnsen | 04/21/2008 5:05 PM

steyn_lincolnclub.jpgThis past Saturday evening I enjoyed a two-fold benefit I will not soon forget: Not only did I hear Mark Steyn deliver the annual address at the 46th annual dinner of the Lincoln Club of Orange County (a prestigious and highly influential political group I am blessed to work with), but I also was privileged to sit with Mr. Steyn at the dinner, enjoying an unforgettable dialogue along the way.  I have reviewed Mark Steyn's masterpiece, America Alone, here and I reiterate my deep admiration for his work in that book, and his editorial giftedness.  I have no doubt that few, if any, political commentators today possess his wit, competence, and intellectual capability.  I have no doubt whatsoever that no member of the op-ed community comes close to possessing his humor and rhetorical skill.  All that Steyn has to offer is deeply needed.  But allow me to expand ...
 
I asked Mr. Steyn at dinner if he employed a research staff of sorts (virtual, volunteer, or otherwise), in his massive gathering of various follies he writes about covering the globe (readers familiar with Steyn know that he has an uncanny ability of reporting on various reduction ad absurdums prevalent in modern culture - particularly in Western Europe).  Mark replied that he did, indeed, uncover all such anecdotes on his own, but that I need not be overly impressed with this work ethic and intelligence. 

"You see, David," Mark said, "when merely reading the mainstream newspapers of Western Europe, finding preposterous stories illustrating Europe's love affair with relativism and political correctness is like shooting fish in a barrel; it doesn't take much." 

Steyn represents a lot to me in the various issues he chooses to harp on week after week.  I believe he is a true lover of America and the ideals that made her great.  He is the most articulate writer out there of the utter evil it represents to simply bail out on Iraq.  I strongly doubt any ivory tower intellectual understands the study of demography the way Mark does.  He attacks political correctness and America-bashing and all sorts of annoyances like these with a rare blend of persuasiveness and mockery.  And yet, if I had to pinpoint the underlying thesis of this man's career, it is this:  Mark Steyn is the [almost] lone prophet in the wilderness screaming for America to get the track she is on towards being Western Europe Part Deux.  And I can not think of a more important calling in life than that ..
 
Mark began his speech Saturday by telling the audience he was a legal immigrant from Canada, now living in New Hampshire.  In reference to his status as a "legal immigrant", he commented that he would "not make that mistake again".  When the audience was done roaring in laughter, he referenced President Bush's line that illegal immigrants are doing the jobs Americans will not do (a sentiment I largely agree with).  Steyn went on to say, though, that having read the LA Times cover-to-cover from his hotel room that morning, he had no idea one of the jobs Americans apparently refuse to do is write something like a readable newspaper in the the second largest media market in the country.  Amen to that.
 
Much of his speech was given to the plethora of reasons to abhor a Barrack Obama Presidency.  In quoting Obama's sworn commitment to leaving Iraq, with no deference to the state of affairs on the ground there, Mark pointed out that Obama is either a fraud (in the event that he does follow the General's advice and finish the matter at hand), or a buffoon (in the event that he actually does what he says he is going to do, and leave those people to suffer the fate the South Vietnamese and Cambodians suffered in 1974).  Why, Mark wonders, would we even tolerate the choice between a fraud and a buffoon?  While Mark is not a religion writer, one of the things I most enjoy in his work is the extraordinary sense of moral clarity with which he speaks and writes.  The proposed all-in surrender of America in Iraq is not, for Mark, a political issue; it is one of pivotal moral importance (as he references the skull count of past countries we have abandoned prematurely after committing to building their stability).  The Jeremiah Wright affair was not a funny case of a race-baiter, and charlatan who lives in a $1.6 million home in an all-white community (though he surely is both of those things); the Jeremiah Wright story is a classic case of a fraud, shamelessly telling people that sexual immorality and promiscuity are not the problem, but rather the conspiracies of the United States government.  Steyn can mock with the best of them, but ultimately these are issues of tremendous ethical consequence to him.  I wish that it were so with many professed religious leaders in today's issue canvas.
 
Mark brilliantly dismantled the notion that big government pie-in-the-sky ought to be the solution to American ills.  He expressed sheer confusion at the notion that we can cure all disease as a government, provide health insurance to every man, woman, and child as a government, keep every financially insolvent homeowner in their current residences as a government, and yet somehow, sit totally unable to build a fence along the southern border.  As is always the case with liberals, their selectivity in determining what Uncle Sam can and can not do is remarkable.
 
Mark and I enjoyed an extensive talk about the state of much of the religious west in today's scene.  In particular, Mark is very astute in his commentary on the tragedy that is becoming the modern Episcopal church.  The recent attempts of the archbishop, Rowan Williams, to encourage the alternate legal system of sharia in the midst of British jurisprudence became an instant target for Steyn's devastating scorn.  He emotionally pointed out to me that while Ugandan and Rwandan Anglicans are literally being butchered by the thousands at the hands of Islamic tyrants, the best mother England's church has to offer them is more and more literature on the need for gay clergy.  It is a despicable state of affairs, and one Mark surprised me with his mastery over.  To further see his stellar critique at the Christian church's ineptness in the modern age, read this concluding line from his latest back cover article in National Review.
 
"... the most effective strategy against the resurgence of Islam may be the oldest of all - an evangelizing Christianity.  As I said, that's the good news - if you're so inclined.  To the cowed accommodationist governments of a largely post-Christian Christendom, it no doubt sounds like the worst news of all."
 
Ouch.  And yet, painfully true.
 
Mark lamented in his speech that,

"the Democrats are doing all they can to catch up to Western Europe; it does not give us Republicans the right to do everything we can to catch up to the democrats."
He is deeply bothered by the Republican's default choice of John McCain as their nominee, yet also keenly aware of the disaster the alternative represents.
 
But through the humor, wit, and broad array of subjects Steyn covers, it is his fundamental pro-America, pro-individual, pro-morality, pro-freedom worldview that we see him so sharply contrasted to the elitist, humanist, relativist, statist flavors of the day.  Steyn is plenty willing to be critical of deficit spending run amok, but expresses amazement at the reason most Americans are so bothered.
 
"This is not merely about the fact that we can not afford all of these government programs that have created the deficits we have today.  Indeed, if Bill Gates wanted to write a check each and every day to help Uncle Sam pay for them, it does nothing to change the fact that these are still wrong programs.  A society that learns to be this dependent on government is a society that weakens to the point of decay, and extinction."
 
For Mark, this nanny-welfarism that has parasitically spread throughout the soul and body of Western Europe is why it is no impotent to defend itself against the ills that threaten it.  Shrinking economies, upside-down family trees (four grandparents, two parents, and one child - the classic recipe for demographic extinction), and complete moral chaos, are merely the symptoms of what is plaguing the secularized Western bloc of our friends across the pond.  What has done them in is a love affair with 30-hour work weeks, six-week vacations, and an unending retort of "just say yes" to the questions of what government ought to be doing in their society.  Greece's 25% of GDP pension costs are not the problem; they are the result that has stemmed from the real problem - nanny-welfarism run amok.
 
Steyn is like the prophet in the wilderness screaming to us Americans to pull it together, or face the same fate as the once great continent of Europe.  The will of the American population is being severely tested,  For me and my family, we will go down swinging at any attempt to Western-Europize our great country.  For Barrack Obama, Hillary Clinton, and today's democratic party, the choice has already been made.  Americans may not hear the truth regarding radical Islam, and dangerous demography, and nanny-welfarism in the mainstream press, or in the pews of their church.  But fortunately, there are still folks like Mark Steyn humorously and powerfully delivering the truth.  Theirs is a formidable opponent.  We are wise to join them in the fight for the future of the American Way.
CATEGORY: FEATURE

Comments

Chuck DeVore said:

Thanks for taking the time to write this. I was over at the Pacific Justice Institute dinner with Fred Barnes and Hugh Hewitt. Also very interesting.

All the best,

Chuck DeVore
State Assemblyman, 70th District
www.chuckdevore.com

MrWhipple said:

It's Steyn's stock in trade to name-call and misrepresent when he can't come up with a good argument. There can't be any good reasons for withdrawing from Iraq, he demurs, so those who support such a withdrawal (including 1/3 of Republicans, such as myself) are either "buffoons" or "frauds."

The fact is that there are good reasons to believe that an orderly withdrawal on a specified timetable will spur the Iraqis into making necessary political changes that will end their dependence on the American military presence. The alternative is a never-ending, but massively expensive and bloody, American occupation of a country we never should have invaded in the first place.

Instead of adding to thoughtful and substantive debate, Mark Steyn has instead chosen the road of smug condescension.

redperegrine said:

Sorry, Whip, but I guess you haven't heard the news - per our standard bearer McCain. Iraq is to be America's version of the 100 Years War. Hooray for the good old days of Europe!

David L. Bahnsen said:

Steyn addressed the specific position that "no matter what is going on, and no matter what the generals say, and no matter where things stand in the reason, I am going to withdraw, no matter what."

Steyn is being charitable to merely refer to such a position as buffoon-esque. But you already knew that.

And as for the 100 year comment above, the term "fraud" or "buffoon" is worth mentioning again. Posters need to demonstrate some integrity when spouting off. Purposeful and gross misrepresentation of your opponent's position is hardly necessary in this situation - plenty of legitimate (though unconvincing) arguments exist.

Anonymous said:

Sorry, Mr. Bahnsen, I thought I remembered McCain "spouting off" about being in Iraq for 100 years. Was I wrong? The idea of being bogged down in Iraq indefinitely doesn't bother some people, evidently - but it bothers me - especially when co-joined to a discussion about why America shouldn't end up like sissy, effete Western Europe. There is an insidious message there, alright.

My "opponent's position"? I have to confess my ignorance - I never even heard of Mark Steyn before your post. He's not my "opponent." What I am opposed to is an open-ended quagmire that was ill-considered and is paid for on credit - your kid's credit, actually. If that prompts what you consider fraudulent or buffoonish commentary on my part - well, amen, brother.

David L. Bahnsen said:

Yes, Anonymous. You are wrong. Libelously wrong. Please google McCain's actual words and you tell me if the 100 year remark is being presented to you honestly. You will maintain your opposition to this war after reading the real quote, but at least you will no longer use it in the context you did above. McCain never, ever said what you said he said. It sounds like, though, you were simply quoting what others (obviously in the MSM) lied to you about.

redperegrine said:

From CNN (MSM):

Last month, at a town hall meeting in New Hampshire, a crowd member asked McCain about a Bush statement that troops could stay in Iraq for 50 years.

"Maybe 100," McCain replied. "As long as Americans are not being injured or harmed or wounded or killed, it's fine with me and I hope it would be fine with you if we maintain a presence in a very volatile part of the world where al Qaeda is training, recruiting, equipping and motivating people every single day"

Who is going to pay for that presence, Mr. Bahnsen? Not you or Mr. Steyn, evidently, since our president doesn't seem have the courage to ask anybody to pay for it.

8AF said:

So when is Mark Steyn signing up to go fight in Iraq?

I always like how ideologues like Steyn believe in a cause where someone else is doing both the sacrificing and dying.

Select a Red County Blog

MEET THE LOCAL EDITOR
 
 

Recent Comments

11/22/2008 9:23 AM

Anongymous commented about: How Liberal is Gus Ayer?

Mr. Ayer registered as a Republican to be electable in an interim election with no incumbents. He did...
 

11/20/2008 1:39 PM

John Hewitt commented about: The Darrell Nolta Drinking Game

Anonymous, you have an excellent point. Sometimes people become annoyed by a person or event, to the extent...
 

11/20/2008 2:33 AM

meme commented about: Seasons Greetings to Our Friends...

It’s Christmas again!! A time to cherish the beautiful white snow, smiling snowman, brightness of the Christmas décor...
 

11/19/2008 7:35 PM

orange county og commented about: Gang Members? What Gang members?

hahaha kpc veteran kpc is a wanabe gang that started like a pary crew then a gang how...
 

11/18/2008 11:47 PM

Fred Smoller commented about: More Details On Steve Rocco's Catsup Caper

you can see the documentary I made about him at recallingrocco "dot" com....
 

11/16/2008 10:02 PM

anonymous commented about: Todd Gallinger is the fourth member of "Keep Irvine Great"

Ed Anger, Get your facts straight. Its sad how ignorant people can be. The fact that he's muslim...
 

11/15/2008 4:01 PM

Grizzly commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Disarming law-abiding citizens in the guise of protecting the community is counterintuitive. As you know, law enforcement cannot...
 

11/15/2008 1:38 PM

Blues commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Just another reason to put on my list of things that need to be fixed in California before...
 

11/15/2008 12:25 PM

F&E Fan commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

The judges did not invent a right out of thin air, Jubal. They did their job in determining...
 

11/15/2008 12:16 PM

Bill commented about: Post-Victory Observations On Prop. 8

The loud call for opponents of Prop. 8 to “get over it and accept the will of the...
 

11/15/2008 9:05 AM

COTOBLOGZZ commented about: Sociopoly and the Fanny Playing Card Deck

Excellent - perhaps THAT card deck can be used for Sociopoly, adding GM Executives in some sort of...
 

11/15/2008 12:43 AM

Jubal commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

It's not hysteria, Missy. That would be the tone of your comments here, which are starting to take...
 

11/14/2008 10:58 PM

BigGuy commented about: Sociopoly and the Fanny Playing Card Deck

I have a Freddie Mac playing card deck that was used as a promotional item at recruitment fairs....
 

11/14/2008 10:57 PM

No Dah...Chris commented about: Update on Orange County's Closest Races - Garden Grove, Westminster, Yorba Linda, and SAUSD

Chris Emami, boy you sure daring to stick your neck out by declaring Andrew Do the winner. Any...
 

11/14/2008 9:29 PM

ADP commented about: Moorlach and Norby On CCWs

Mr Moorlach and his part time "law professor" have not been given all the facts. The new "verifiable...
 

11/14/2008 9:22 PM

Missy commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

"What Kevin is threatening would be the equivalent of seeking out my clients and threatening to make examples...
 

11/14/2008 9:16 PM

PMS commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

The more I read on the current situation of the CCW policy in Orange County the more concerned...
 

11/14/2008 9:09 PM

JDAP commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Supervisor Norby; Thank you standing up for what's right instead of what is politically correct. Any man or...
 

11/14/2008 7:58 PM

Jubal commented about: Same-Sex Marriage Advocates Continue Threatening Yes on 8 Supporters

What is being attempted is a boycott of businesses owned by people who DONATED to the Yes on...
 

11/14/2008 6:59 PM

Tiki commented about: Kudos To Chris Norby On CCWs

Thank you Supervisor Norby....
 

What We're Talking About