Profile | Fred Edwards
Website | Crosshairs - Military Matters in Review
Author's Latest Posts |
- Is there a war going on? Does only 1 percent care?
- North Korea shatters U.S. preemption policy
- North Korea cocks the trigger
- An American military ethos: What’s wrong with it?
- Muslim fanatics and American courts: Square pegs and round holes
More»
Guns in Mexico: Numbers Do Lie
By Fred Edwards | 04/13/09 | 09:51 AM EDT | 4 Comments
If Secretary of State Hillary Clinton tells reporters on a flight to Mexico City that 90 percent of the weapons used to commit crimes in Mexico come from the United States, it must be accurate, right?
If CBS newsman Bob Schieffer refers to the same percentage while interviewing President Obama, it has to be correct, right?
And if Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., says at a Senate hearing: "It is unacceptable to have 90 percent of the guns that are picked up in Mexico and used to shoot judges, police officers and mayors . . . come from the United States," then 90 percent of the guns must come from America, right?
On top of all that, if William Hoover from the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, tells the House of Representatives "there is more than enough evidence to indicate that over 90 percent of the firearms that have either been recovered in, or interdicted in transport to Mexico, originated from various sources within the United States," that ought to settle the issue, right?
Well, think again. On April 2, William La Jeunesse and Maxim Lott of FOX News stated, “It's just not true.” They said that only 17 percent of guns found at Mexican crime scenes have been traced to the United States. They added that an ATF spokeswoman confirmed this by saying that over 90 percent of the guns that Mexico traces originated in the United States. Many aren’t sent to the United States for tracing because their markings show they didn’t come from the U.S. market.
Let’s look at the numbers. La Jeunesse and Lott stated that, in 2007 and 2008, the Mexican government reported recovering 29,000 guns at crime scenes. ATF Special Agent William Newell said that Mexico submitted only 11,000 guns to the ATF for tracing. Almost 6,000 were traced successfully, and 5,114 were determined to come from the United States.
To put the numbers into perspective, of the 29,000 guns found at crime scenes, 5,114, or 17.6 percent were actually traced to the United States. That’s a far cry from the 90 percent figure that has been tossed around.
Where did all the other weapons originate? La Jeunesse and Lott documented an international armory, beginning with “fragmentation grenades from South Korea, AK-47s from China, and shoulder-fired rocket launchers from Spain, Israel and former Soviet bloc manufacturers.” Other sources on their list:
- Russian criminal groups such as Poldolskaya and Solntsevskaya
- The Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia (FARC), in league with the Tijuana cartel
- Asia
- Deserters from the Mexican Army
- Guatemala
Why this insistence on 90 percent versus 17.6 percent? Chris Cox of the National Rifle Association blames the media and anti-gun politicians, saying “The numbers are intentionally used to weaken the Second Amendment.” In line with La Jeunesse and Lott, he mentioned weapons found in Mexico that did not come from the United States, such as Russian, Chinese and Israeli guns, and weapons from Mexican army deserters.
Although a look at the numbers discloses that they can be used to mislead Americans, the hard figure of 5,114 weapons traced to the United States in a two-year period remains a serious factor. But if the United States and Mexico are going to partner in this war that’s spilling over our borders, let’s keep American left-wing gun-control spin out of it. After all, law-abiding Americans living in the border states need their own guns now, more than ever before.
Courtesy: Military Matters in Review by Fred Edwards. Visit http://www.milmat.net for more Crosshairs.
TAGS: Mexico, guns, National Rifle Association, FOX News
4 Comments | Related Topics »National
RECOMMENDED SITES
















Comments
So the Obama administration is lying to us? OH NO! About guns?
As a Pakistani gun shopper Sifarish Khan said, "A gun can be your friend", comparing gun ownership to having loyal friends at your side. "More bullets, more friends".
- reply
|Hillarious Hillary at it again! Fine for her to say that everyday citizens don't have the need to protect themselves when afterall, it was HER husband BILL CLINTON that signed a bill extending personal armed security forces to protect him, Chelsea and his wife for an ADDITIONAL SIX YEARS at taxpayer expense. It used to be TWO YEARS. This is the same Billary that wanted scanners on every street corner in New York to detect if anyone was carry a gun. She's outta her mind. Her and Obama make up numbers and BS as it suits their needs. They seem to be the only ones whose lives can be protected the rest of us be damned. The Tea Parties need to ramp it up.
- reply
|US Government contractors like FN and Colt sold a lot of military arms to South American countries.
Now for some convenient reason, the Mexican Government is unable to produce the serial numbers of some captured military rifles, M16 and M4 rifles.
You can download a .PDF of "A Guide to the US Small Arms Market, Industry and Exports,1998–2004" By Tamar Gabelnick, Maria Haug, and Lora Lumpe.
Web site: www.smallarmssurvey.org
Bottom line: They are lying about the numbers of firearms, these firearms were given to South American countries around the same time Chavez came into power, and lets face it, there are plenty of people in South America that would set up their own "Lease Lend" program as they will profit themselves from the drug trade.
- reply
|As a proud gun carrying American, I believe in the numbers that have been produced. The fact of the matter is every time I travel to Mexico I am never stopped and searched. There is a truck inspection pull off right passed the boarder crossing yet I have never seen a U.S. truck being inspected. The fact may be the yes the arms are comming in from the U.S. but what are our Mexican neighbors doing to try and stem the problem. The fact is this is a two front war one entering Mexico from the U.S. and one from Mexico to the U.S.. The global drug trade is far reaching and with states and the federal government now scrambling for cash my money is on the drug dealers.
- reply
|Post new comment